Ports with one resource, nearest first.
| 1 | Frozen Cay | United States | shallow | Production | — | — | 55 |
| 2 | Green Cay | Sverige | shallow | Production | — | — | 59 |
| 3 | Sandy Point | Neutral | shallow | Production | — | — | 103 |
| 4 | Road Rocks | United States | shallow | Production | — | — | 109 |
| 5 | Cayo Romano | España | deep | Production | — | — | 136 |
| 6 | Key West | United States | deep | Player contracts | 50 | 1,915 | 212 |
| 7 | Watlings | Pirates | shallow | Production | — | — | 214 |
| 8 | San Sebastian | United States | deep | Production | — | — | 217 |
| 9 | Puerto del Padre | Pirates | deep | Production | — | — | 230 |
| 10 | Atwoods | Sverige | deep | Production | — | — | 277 |
| 11 | Las Tortugas | Neutral | deep | Production | — | — | 286 |
| 12 | New Smyrna | United States | deep | Production | — | — | 289 |
| 13 | Baracoa | Pirates | deep | Production | — | — | 327 |
| 14 | Mortimer Town | Pirates | deep | Player contracts | 435 | 599 | 336 |
| 15 | Cayo del Anclote | Neutral | deep | Production | — | — | 373 |
| 16 | Saint Marys | United States | deep | Production | — | — | 394 |
| 17 | Puerto Escondido | Pirates | deep | Production | — | — | 405 |
| 18 | Port-de-Paix | Verenigde Provinciën | deep | Production | — | — | 410 |
| 19 | Lorimers | Pirates | deep | Production | — | — | 410 |
| 20 | Las Sabinas | Neutral | shallow | Production | — | — | 428 |
| 21 | Port-au-Prince | Verenigde Provinciën | deep | Production | — | — | 489 |
| 22 | Pinar del Río | España | deep | Production | — | — | 492 |
| 23 | Kidd's Harbour | United States | deep | Production | — | — | 521 |
| 24 | Siguanea | España | shallow | Production | — | — | 546 |
| 25 | Little River | United States | deep | Production | — | — | 548 |
| 26 | Kingston / Port Royal | Great Britain | deep | Player contracts | 500 | 1,698 | 569 |
| 27 | Bahía Escocesa | Danmark-Norge | deep | Production | — | — | 572 |
| 28 | Jacmel | Verenigde Provinciën | deep | Production | — | — | 582 |
| 29 | Pedro Cay | Great Britain | shallow | Production | — | — | 615 |
| 30 | Tulum | Great Britain | deep | Production | — | — | 616 |