Pick a home port to map where to sell each item. Until then, prices are the best anywhere.
40 craftable items shops buy.
| 12pd Long Gun | Pitt's Town | 765 | 387 | 378 | 1,241 | 469,408 | |
| 42pd Long Gun | Pitt's Town | 1,016 | 700 | 316 | 604 | 191,015 | |
| Rum | Nassau | 10 | 5.26 | 4.74 | 43,750 | 207,200 | |
| Grape Ammo | Nassau | 6 | 3.76 | 2.24 | 87,500 | 196,000 | |
| Chain Ammo | Nassau | 7 | 4.84 | 2.16 | 43,750 | 94,500 | |
| Ball Ammo | Pitt's Town | 2 | 1.82 | 0.18 | 175,000 | 31,500 | |
| Charcoal | Bahía Escocesa | 1 | 1 | 0 | 175,000 | 0 | |
| Oak Planks | La Mona | 1 | 1 | 0 | 175,000 | 0 | |
| Sail Canvas | Santo Tomé de Guayana | 1 | 1 | 0 | 175,000 | 0 | |
| Iron Fittings | La Tortuga | 1 | 2 | -1 | 87,500 | -87,500 | |
| Gunpowder | La Tortuga | 1 | 4.27 | -3.27 | 350,000 | -1,144,500 | |
| Barrels | Mimbres | 1 | 6.20 | -5.20 | 116,666 | -606,663 | |
| Ropes and Blocks | Turtle Cay | 1 | 6.60 | -5.60 | 26,923 | -150,769 | |
| Medicine | Nassau | 9 | 29.14 | -20.14 | 70,000 | -1,409,800 | |
| Hull Repairs | Nassau | 34 | 57.60 | -23.60 | 17,500 | -413,000 | |
| Provisions | Nassau | 9 | 38.94 | -29.94 | 9,210 | -275,747 | |
| 9pd Long Gun | Pitt's Town | 305 | 339 | -34.33 | 1,446 | -49,646 | |
| 32pd Long Gun | Pitt's Town | 556 | 592 | -36.42 | 718 | -26,147 | |
| Rig Repairs | Nassau | 30 | 89.50 | -59.50 | 17,500 | -1,041,250 | |
| 4pd Medium Gun | Nassau | 25 | 88.33 | -63.33 | 2,916 | -184,680 | |
| 24pd Long Gun | Pitt's Town | 409 | 494 | -85.08 | 847 | -72,066 | |
| 6pd Medium Gun | Nassau | 29 | 132 | -103 | 2,147 | -220,246 | |
| 6pd Long Gun | Nassau | 115 | 224 | -109 | 1,741 | -190,349 | |
| 9pd Medium Gun | Nassau | 34 | 175 | -141 | 1,794 | -252,506 | |
| 18pd Long Gun | Pitt's Town | 305 | 447 | -142 | 1,011 | -143,225 | |
| 4pd Long Gun | Nassau | 31 | 177 | -146 | 2,333 | -340,424 | |
| 12pd Carronade | La Habana | 29 | 212 | -183 | 3,333 | -609,384 | |
| 12pd Medium Gun | Tolú | 38 | 226 | -188 | 1,548 | -291,540 | |
| 18pd Carronade | Nassau | 35 | 259 | -224 | 2,380 | -533,715 | |
| 18pd Medium Gun | Port-de-Paix | 44 | 270 | -226 | 1,272 | -286,836 | |
| 32pd Carronade | Pitt's Town | 254 | 495 | -241 | 1,422 | -343,058 | |
| 24pd Medium Gun | San Juan | 48 | 359 | -311 | 1,070 | -333,127 | |
| 24pd Carronade | Pitt's Town | 39 | 385 | -346 | 1,842 | -636,411 | |
| 32pd Medium Gun | Pedernales | 53 | 403 | -350 | 909 | -317,771 | |
| 36pd Long Gun | Pitt's Town | 286 | 640 | -354 | 630 | -222,915 | |
| 36pd Medium Gun | Cartagena de Indias | 58 | 446 | -388 | 800 | -310,267 | |
| 42pd Carronade | Pitt's Town | 191 | 582 | -391 | 1,121 | -438,218 | |
| 42pd Medium Gun | Xpu Ha | 63 | 489 | -426 | 769 | -327,594 | |
| 68pd Carronade | Pitt's Town | 191 | 689 | -498 | 695 | -346,284 | |
| 13 Inch Mortar | Little Inagua | 1,266 | 141,641 | -140,375 | 408 | -57,273,000 |