| Aguadilla | Great Britain | Puerto Rico | San Juan | deep | Large | 3,300 | 50 | 5% | 9,728 |
| Almirante | Great Britain | Central America | Matina | deep | Medium | 1,450 | 30 | 5% | — |
| Amalienborg | Great Britain | Upper Antilles | Spanish Town | deep | Medium | 1,450 | 30 | 5% | 4,750 |
| Arthur's Town | Neutral | Bahamas | George's Town | shallow | not capturable | — | 30 | 5% | — |
| Aves | Verenigde Provinciën | Central Antilles | deep | not capturable | — | 30 | 5% | — | |
| Ays | France | Atlantic Coast | Ays | deep | Medium | 1,450 | 30 | 5% | 15,761 |
| Bahía Escocesa | Great Britain | Hispaniola | Puerto Plata | deep | Medium | 1,450 | 30 | 5% | 1,915 |
| Baja | España | West Cuba | La Habana | deep | Medium | 1,450 | 30 | 5% | 3,000 |
| Baracoaregional | España | East Cuba | Baracoa | deep | Large | 6,000 | 55 | 5% | 5,129 |
| Barahona | Pirates | Hispaniola | Santo Domingo | deep | Medium | 2,975 | 40 | 5% | 864 |
| Basse-Terreregional | Great Britain | Central Antilles | Pointe-à-Pitre | deep | Medium | 1,450 | 30 | 5% | 2,500 |
| Basseterre Town | Pirates | Upper Antilles | Saint John's | deep | Large | 3,300 | 50 | 5% | 4,960 |
| Belize | España | Central America | Belize | deep | Large | 6,000 | 55 | 5% | — |
| Bensalem | Great Britain | Central America | Belize | deep | Medium | 2,975 | 40 | 5% | — |
| Bimini | Pirates | Bahamas | Morgan's Bluff | shallow | Small | 325 | 30 | 5% | 40 |
| Black River | Pirates | Central America | Black River | deep | Medium | 1,450 | 30 | 5% | 560 |
| Bluefields | France | Central America | Bluefields | deep | Large | 6,000 | 55 | 5% | 100,064 |
| Bonacca | Great Britain | Central America | Black River | deep | Medium | 1,450 | 30 | 5% | — |
| Bone Cay | Great Britain | Jamaica | Pedro Cay | shallow | Small | 325 | 30 | 5% | 5 |
| Brangman's Bluff | Pirates | Central America | Brangman's Bluff | deep | Medium | 1,450 | 30 | 5% | — |
| Bridgetown | Pirates | Lower Antilles | Bridgetown | deep | Large | 6,000 | 55 | 5% | 516,268 |
| Brunswick | España | Atlantic Coast | Savannah | deep | Medium | 1,450 | 30 | 5% | — |
| Cabo Cañaveral | Pirates | Atlantic Coast | Ays | deep | Medium | 2,975 | 40 | 5% | 2,133 |
| Cabo de la Vela | Pirates | South America | Santa Marta | deep | Large | 3,300 | 50 | 5% | — |
| Calobelo | Great Britain | Central America | Portobelo | deep | Medium | 2,975 | 40 | 5% | — |
| Camp du Roy | Pirates | Central Antilles | Pointe-à-Pitre | deep | Medium | 2,975 | 40 | 5% | — |
| Campecheregional | Great Britain | Yucatan | Campeche | deep | Large | 6,000 | 55 | 5% | — |
| Canalete | Pirates | South America | Cartagena de Indias | deep | Large | 3,300 | 50 | 5% | — |
| Cap-Françaisregional | España | Hispaniola | Cap-Français | deep | Large | 6,000 | 55 | 5% | 24,850 |
| Caracasregional | Great Britain | South America | Caracas | deep | Large | 6,000 | 55 | 5% | — |
| Cartagena de Indiasregional | Pirates | South America | Cartagena de Indias | deep | Large | 6,000 | 55 | 5% | 71,160 |
| Casigua | Great Britain | South America | Maracaibo | deep | Large | 3,300 | 50 | 5% | 3,764 |
| Cayman Brac | Great Britain | Jamaica | George Town | deep | Medium | 1,450 | 30 | 5% | — |
| Cayo Biscayno | España | Atlantic Coast | Ays | deep | Large | 3,300 | 50 | 5% | 15,024 |
| Cayo Romano | España | West Cuba | Remedios | deep | Large | 3,300 | 50 | 5% | 1,643 |
| Caño Araguao | Great Britain | South America | Santo Tomé de Guayana | deep | Large | 3,300 | 50 | 5% | — |
| Champotón | Great Britain | Yucatan | Campeche | deep | Medium | 2,975 | 40 | 5% | — |
| Charleston | France | Atlantic Coast | Charleston | deep | Large | 6,000 | 55 | 5% | 229,039 |
| Chinchorro | Great Britain | Yucatan | Salamanca | shallow | Small | 325 | 30 | 5% | — |
| Christiansted | Great Britain | Upper Antilles | Christiansted | deep | Large | 6,000 | 55 | 5% | 108,760 |
| Codrington | Great Britain | Upper Antilles | Saint John's | deep | Medium | 1,450 | 30 | 5% | — |
| Concepción | Great Britain | Central America | Matina | deep | Large | 3,300 | 50 | 5% | — |
| Congrios | España | Yucatan | Salamanca | deep | Large | 3,300 | 50 | 5% | — |
| Conil | España | Yucatan | Sisal | deep | Large | 3,300 | 50 | 5% | — |
| Coquibacoa | Pirates | South America | Santa Marta | deep | Medium | 2,975 | 40 | 5% | — |
| Coro | Great Britain | South America | Caracas | deep | Medium | 1,450 | 30 | 5% | — |
| Corrientes | España | West Cuba | Pinar del Río | deep | Large | 3,300 | 50 | 5% | 1,000 |
| Croata | Great Britain | Central America | Black River | shallow | Small | 325 | 30 | 5% | — |
| Crown Haven | Neutral | Bahamas | Marsh Harbour | shallow | not capturable | — | 30 | 5% | — |
| Cumanáregional | Great Britain | South America | Cumaná | deep | Large | 6,000 | 55 | 5% | — |